Mar 15, 2018

RH Links - 3/15/18

QUOTE OF THE DAY

Pity the poor fellow who doesn’t write. He likely cannot think. Rayward  

RETIREMENT FINANCE AND PLANNING

After all these years of retirement modeling, I still don’t get very fancy when doing my own calculations. I model the basic factors that I can predict with some accuracy. Then I live frugally, maintain a healthy cushion to guard against the unknown, and don’t spend much time or effort trying to predict how the future will unfold… For most of us, a middle way works best 

SWPs provide a retiree with an algorithm for withdrawing funds from their investment portfolio.  Sometimes this is also referred to as “tapping” one’s savings.   Common examples are the 4% Rule and the IRS RMD approach…. A Sustainable Spending Plan develops a spending budget that is consistent with the individual’s (or couple’s) spending goals… The focus of the SSP is on spending, not withdrawals from savings.  [I'm going to have to agree with Ken on this.  Withdrawal methodologies often get confused with spending but are not the same.  An annuity is a type of "withdrawal plan" and a person would be blessed if their spending exactly matched the annuity cash flow...but it won't] 

two recent studies … aim to tip the odds when it comes to spending from a portfolio. 

Retirees need to make two critical financial decisions, namely, the withdrawal rate and the asset allocation of their portfolios. We propose a methodology that retirees, and particularly advisors, could use to make these decisions in an optimal way. We introduce a new variable, the coverage ratio, and a theoretical approach, based on utility. Our approach can be used to make optimal decisions during both the accumulation and the retirement period, but we illustrate it by focusing on the latter, and particularly on the choice of an optimal asset allocation. We find that the strategies selected by our utility-based approach are in general somewhat more aggressive than those selected by the failure rate and other existing approaches. 

In this paper we derive some closed-form expressions for the value of longevity risk pooling with fixed life annuities under constant relative risk aversion preferences. We show, for example, that this value converges to the square root of Euler's e -1 (=65\%), when the interest rate is the inverse of life expectancy, lifetimes are exponentially distributed and utility is logarithmic. In general the various formulae we derive match previously published numerical results, when properly calibrated to discrete time and tables. More importantly, we focus attention on the incremental utility from annuitization when the retiree is already endowed with pre-existing pension income such as Social Security benefits. Indeed, due to the difficulty in working with the so-called wealth depletion time (WDT) in lifecycle models, we believe this is an area that hasn't received proper attention from actuarial researchers. Our paper offers tools to explain the value of longevity risk pooling. 

Consider this hellish scenario: You retire with what you imagine is plenty of money—and you’re immediately hit with a brutal market decline, even as you pull out a growing sum from your portfolio each year to cover rising living expenses. This double drain quickly depletes your savings. A few years later, the markets bounce back. But you don’t benefit much because, by then, your portfolio has been whittled down by your need for spending money. 

MARKETS AND INVESTING



Learning from the Dumb Money, Institutional Investor
High-quality private wealth managers endeavor to understand their clients' goals and create an investment strategy that offers the best chance of achieving those goals. They focus equally on their clients' assets and liabilities. Most of the time, a variety of easily accessible investment options - often low-cost vehicles - can put clients on a likely path to success.  The thoughtful attention to matching an investment strategy with the purpose of the money changes the way advisors spend their time. These wealth managers have little need to spend an inordinate amount of time building relationships to access capacity in the leading India-focused venture capital manager, for example. The pursuit of optimizing investments independent of a holistic understanding of liabilities is irrelevant to the bigger picture.  …. In contrast, institutions spend immense amounts of time fine tuning one side of their balance sheet - the asset side.

I was able to reconcile the practical, intuitive, closed-form-solution optimal portfolio rules of the Markowitz–Tobin mean–variance theory with expected utility theory and a prototypical lognormal return distribution, which doesn’t have the negative-price perversities that a normal one has. When you worked it through, it turned out that when you keep constant proportions—as you would—nothing changed in terms of the risky assets’ distributions. When you trade continuously and combine lognormals, they aggregate to a lognormally distributed portfolio. Therefore, the Markowitz–Tobin two-fund separation theorem obtains as well.  

ALTERNATIVE RISK

“Having faced an extended period of low investor confidence and net capital outflows, the hedge fund industry is now experiencing a renaissance among institutions,” said Amy Bensted, Preqin’s head of hedge fund products, in a release. “2017 saw the asset class mark four quarters of net inflows, and at the start of 2018, the highest proportion of investors in five years are planning to increase their exposure over the year ahead.” 

Contrary to conventional wisdom, investment strategies that take advantage of short-selling can generate relatively low tax burdens. Short positions not only allow investors to benefit from the anticipated underperformance of securities, they also expand the opportunity set for realizing short-term losses, which is particularly beneficial because the short-term capital gains tax rate is substantially higher than the long-term rate. In addition, realized short-term losses are first used to offset highly taxed, short-term capital gains. By employing tax-wise strategies, accelerating capital losses and deferring capital gains, tax burdens are reduced. Short-selling creates tax benefits because the long positions of a portfolio tend to realize net long-term capital gains, which are taxed at relatively low rates, whereas the short positions tend to realize net short-term capital losses, which can offset short-term capital gains realized by other strategies in the investor’s portfolio. The benefits of tax-aware strategies mostly come from losses realized by short positions. As a result, these tax benefits are positively correlated with the market return, because short positions realize tax losses exactly at the time when other investments in the investor’s portfolio are likely to be at a gain. A tax-aware strategy significantly reduces capital gains realizations, and thereby the turnover, of the long-only portfolio. 

The consistency of a trend following strategy’s relative performance vs a 60/40 portfolio (impacting the ability for investors to stick with trend following) is the basis of an argument that’s taken place offline (yes, I also argue offline) with a FinTwit friend who is a huge proponent of buy and hold. It’s progressed to the point that we’ve discussed making a mini (very mini) Buffett style bet related to whether trend following or a 60% US Stock / 40% Bond allocation will outperform over the next five years (with money going to the winner's charity of choice).  

SOCIETY AND CAPITAL

"In the making of the wages contract the individual laborer is at a disadvantage. He has something which he must sell and which his employer is not obliged to take, since he [that is, the employer] can reject single men with impunity. ...  A period of idleness may increase this disability to any extent. The vender of anything which must be sold at once is like a starving man pawning his coat—he must take whatever is offered." John Bates Clark…  
  
…there is currently no generally accepted method of measuring TDF risk. This presents a challenge to policymakers, plan sponsors, plan participants, and financial advisers. The target-date fund industry today is analogous in many ways to the automobile industry of the 1960s. We note a number of issues that this analogy brings to light. The public policy discussion that occurred in the automobile industry then provides a useful framework for interested parties to discuss policy matters in the defined-contribution industry today…  

Road deaths over the long-term, OurWorldInData.org


On Weird Niche Investing. Institutional investor
I was expecting the list to include payday and auto title lenders, strip clubs, porn sites, dark web hacker funds, loot boxes, and companies that develop facial recognition software that scans the faces of men on dating apps to identify those who are married. 

One main result is that the actual evidence is pretty thin. "Of more than 100 combinations of policies and outcomes, we found that surprisingly few were the subject of methodologically rigorous investigation." For example, evidence on four of the eight outcomes was "essentially unavailable," including defensive gun use, officer-involved shootings, hunting and recreation, and effects on the gun industry. None of the studies of waiting periods and licencing and permitting requirements have reached more than inconclusive results. There are no methodologically sound studies at all on the effects of gun-free zones or requirements for reporting of lost or stolen firearms. 

A new NASA statement suggests the physical and mental stresses of Scott Kelly's year in orbit may have activated hundreds of "space genes" that altered the astronaut's immune system, bone formation, eyesight and other bodily processes. While most of these genetic changes reverted to normal following Scott Kelly's return to Earth, about 7 percent of the astronaut's genetic code remained altered — and it may stay that way permanently.  [Alien] 

Ironies of Luck, Morgan Housel
People are good at discounting risks that threaten the continuation of their past success. They are equally good at discounting the role of luck in their past success. What’s the saying? “Like every self-made man, he worshiped his creator.” Calling someone’s past success lucky is insulting, because it undermines the effort that person put into their endeavor. But risk doesn’t care about how much effort you put into something, and neither does luck. Both just show up, unannounced, eager to humble you. The only difference is that risk humbles you as soon as it arrives, while luck humbles you down the road, once it vanishes, leaving you with only the memories you shared together. You can manage risk and luck. You can ignore risk and luck. But you can’t get rid of either. 

It seems the worst is yet to come for California cities already reeling under the strain of rising pension costs. According to a new report from the League of California Cities released after reviewing data for 451 municipalities that use CalPERS to administer their pensions, from fiscal year 2019 to 2025, city payments for pensions will increase an estimated 50%. Pension costs, which consumed an average of 8% of cities’ general fund budgets in 2007, will drain an average 16% by 2025. The bottom line — without tax increases there will be even less money for public services.  






No comments:

Post a Comment