Aug 17, 2017

Weekend Links - 8/17/2017 - The economics of envy and unhappiness



“if people are envious by caring about relative wealth, then free trade may make all parties richer, but may cause envious people to be less happy. If economics misunderstands human nature, then free trade may simultaneously increase wealth and unhappiness.” Burnham, Dunlap, and Stephens (2015)



IMAGE OF THE DAY



RETIREMENT FINANCE AND PLANNING

High Equity Valuations and Retirement, blog.thinknewfound.com
High valuations suggest that retirement withdrawal rates that were once safe may now deliver success rates that are no better - or even worse - than a coin flip.  This outlook is by no means a call for despair, but rather highlights the increasing need for taking control of one’s destiny by controlling both investment and non-investment factors that can improve the odds of successfully meeting one’s retirement goals.  [I haven't thought of Newfound as a retirement or lifecycle finance gurus before but this is pretty insightful] 

Using Robert Shillers data, I have plotted all possible retirement periods from 1871 in the following graphs. Comments are located within the images. Black color inside a square means "portfolio failure" (value is less than zero). All returns are real, meaning including inflation and with reinvested dividends. Diagonal lines show 30-year, 45-year and 60-year periods.  Compared to the Swedish stock market, the US markets appear much more stable, especially around the world wars. On the other hand, the 70s seem to have been harder for the US than for Sweden.  [cool charts]

We examine the consequences of alternative popular investment strategies for the decumulation of funds invested for retirement through a defined contribution pension scheme. We examine in detail the viability of specific ‘safe’ withdrawal rates including the ‘4%-rule’ of Bengen (1994). We find two powerful conclusions; first that smoothing the returns on individual assets by simple trend following techniques is a potent tool to enhance withdrawal rates. Secondly, we show that while diversification across asset classes does lead to higher withdrawal rates than simple equity/bond portfolios, ’smoothing’ returns in itself is far more powerful a tool for raising withdrawal rates. in fact, smoothing the popular equity/bond portfolios (such as the 60/40 portfolio) is in itself an excellent and simple solution to constructing a retirement portfolio. Alternatively, trend following enables portfolios to contain more risky assets, and the greater upside they offer, for the same level of overall risk compared to standard portfolios.  




MARKETS AND INVESTING

Unlike the traditional theory of portfolio growth, this paper imports ideas from evolutionary biology and population genetics, focusing on the relative wealth of an investor rather than on the absolute wealth. Relative wealth is important financially because success and satisfaction are sometimes measured by investors relative to the success of others (Robson 1992, Bakshi and Chen 1996, Clark and Oswald 1996, Clark, Frijters, and Shields 2008, Corneo and Jeanne 1997, Frank 1990, Frank 2011). When one investor is wealthier than the other, that investor should roughly mimic the other’s behavior in being more or less aggressive than the Kelly criterion. Conversely, when one investor is poorer than the other, that investor should roughly act in the opposite manner of the other investor (Orr 2017). https://ssrn.com/abstract=2900509

derives optimal strategy for a game with known payouts and probability, but uncertain limits on total payout and number of betting opportunities. It further develops some general gambling principles applicable to practical risk taking situations in which all parameters are uncertain and robust approximate simple solutions are required.  [interesting but everything I've ever read from Aaron Brown is more opaque than necessary.  It's not just that it is complex it seems like he goes the extra mile to purposely obscure the main point. This is especially true of his book on risk management]

With too many levers to pull, we run the risk of quibbling about a 3% position in gold instead of focusing on the things we can control–and are likely more important–like our risk tolerance or our savings rate.  [Mr. Hoffstein, on the other hand, contra the previous comment, is both smart and readable, quantitatively skilled, and gets to the point.] 

Numerical stochastic dynamic programming is used to explore the effects of stochastic human capital and Social Security on optimal asset allocation and consumption decisions over the lifecycle for typical individuals. Optimal asset allocations are very stock heavy pre-retirement, and quite stock heavy post retirement. Individuals should adopt declining equity allocations while employed, and level to slightly rising equity allocations during a stochastic retirement. Early in the working years almost the entire income should be consumed. Consumption should typically continue to increase until late in retirement, when it will be forced to fall. [I generally make sure I read every word of what G Irlam puts out. He is very severely under-recognized as a savant in the retirement and lifecycle finance universe and probably should be...recognized, that is]

On advisor fees, Bloomberg.
“There are people charging 2 percent or more,” he said. “I don’t know how they get away with it.” … “If financial planning is going to be a profession,” he said, “there’s going to be a need to be a tighter match between what you charge and the service you provide.”   

[This is a ssrn repost of a 2007/9 paper.  This compliments and reiterates many of the ideas in posts I have done in the past on geometric returns and geometric frontiers, posts that I created after reading a number of papers by R Michaud, Mindlin, Meucci, and others. ]   

of Asset Markets. Belkov et al.
In other words, the group of investors using the portfolio rule λ* drives all the others out of the market, which is interpreted in Evolutionary Finance as the property of global (holding for all initial states) evolutionary stability of λ*. [all this is above my paygrade but having taken a rudimentary class in game theory two years ago, I thought the idea in the paper was interesting.  Maybe someone with more math can decode this for me. The interest is also because I just read the book by Andrew Lo on evolutionary finance (more accessible.  Expect to see more of this type of thing in the future.] 
  

ALTERNATIVE RISK

The Quant Quake, 10 years on, extracalpha
there’s more risk of another Quake than there was 10 years ago. In 2017 we’re seeing evidence of crowdedness and poor performance in standard strategies, with alternative data sets exhibiting far stronger performance. Quants need to build systematic processes for evaluating new data sources, and should view alternative data as a prime directive  

YES. When combined into a multifactor bond portfolio, large reductions in tracking error, increases in the information ratio as well as significant alphas were observed. Outperformance relative to the IG and HY bond markets were .78% (sig) for the IG multifactor bond portfolio and 3.31%(sig)  for the HY multifactor bond portfolio. [interesting because I attempt a factor type strategy on fixed income that works pretty well.]

Isaac Newton’s idea of fluents and fluxions changed mathematics, physics and the world. Very briefly, a fluxion is the instantaneous rate of change of a fluent at a given point in time. The Fluxionization™ strategy makes use of these ideas and probability theory to trade long-only S&P 100 stocks.  [I believe that Fluxionization goes by another name: calculus.  Also not sure why it is proprietary but maybe he has some secret sauce...]

We identify a ‘slope’ factor in exchange rates. High interest rate currencies load more on this slope factor than low interest rate currencies. This factor accounts for most of the cross-sectional variation in average excess returns between high and low interest rate currencies. A standard, no-arbitrage model of interest rates with two factors – a country-specific factor and a global factor – can replicate these findings, provided there is sufficient heterogeneity in exposure to global or common innovations. We show that our slope factor identifies these common shocks, and we provide empirical evidence that it is related to changes in global equity market volatility. By investing in high interest rate currencies and borrowing in low interest rate currencies, US investors load up on global risk.  

When Winning Isn’t Enough, Sean McLaughlin
Let’s say this new market wizard is pulling 5–10% profits on his capital out of the market consistently every month. These are BIG TIME numbers. Legends are born with these numbers. But if he’s trading a $25,000 account, this means his net profits are $1250-$2500 per month. Respectable, but tough to pay for rent/mortgage, debts, car payments, and groceries. And God forbid he should experience a garden variety pullback in his performance!   [While I find his recent string of posts to be depressing, he does speak the truth to trading platitudes]

Skewness and Momentum, Yuecheng Jia and Shu Yan
We document two opposite effects of return skewness on momentum profits. For individual stocks, momentum profits decrease with skewness while for industry portfolios, momentum profits increase with skewness. The findings cannot be explained by existing risk factors and stock characteristics. For individual stocks, the evidence is consistent with the behavioral theory of return skewness as well as the skewness preference theory. For industry portfolios, the evidence is consistent with the interpretation of portfolio skewness as a measure of asymmetric inefficiency.


SOCIETY AND CAPITAL

Of all the corrupters of moral sentiments, therefore, faction and fanaticism have always been by far the greatest." 

Today’s infographic from Information is Beautiful breaks down the demographics of 23 major tech companies, based on statistics from 2016. It also provides comparisons to the composition of the U.S. population in general, the top 50 U.S. companies, Congress, and Fortune 500 CEOs.  

No comments:

Post a Comment