Mar 10, 2017

Weekend Links - 3/10/17

QUOTE OF THE DAY

But in investing, it doesn’t work that way. More resources, more time spent, more effort, etc to do not necessarily lead to better outcomes... If it were simply a case of effort, then the people who trade all day, every day, and never turn off the screens would be the wealthiest.  Josh Brown 

CHART OF THE DAY



RETIREMENT FINANCE AND PLANNING


Annuities: All or Nothing, Dirk Cotton. Economic studies are much better at teaching us how things work than at predicting outcomes for an individual household…Milevsky [2007] shows that the optimal age to buy an All-or-Nothing annuity is when the retiree values the return on an annuity the same as she values the return that she expects from her investments. 

Longevity Risk: To Bear or to Insure? Boon Briere Werker. Tilburg Univ. The collective agreement yields marginally higher individual welfare than an annuity contract priced at its best estimate, and the annuity provider is incapable of adequately compensating its equity holders for bearing longevity risk. Therefore, market-provided annuity contracts would not co-exist with collective schemes. 


Diversification: More Important Now Than Ever. Cordant. For anyone nearing retirement, and therefore nearing the end of the capital accumulation phase of life, reducing the magnitude and duration of losses is crucial. Not only does it matter from a capital preservation and return compounding perspective, but also it’s critical from a behavior perspective… But, perhaps the biggest benefit to building a diversified portfolio is an increased safe withdrawal rate—meaning additional spending in retirement… And, even making the simple change of moving from the 60/40 US portfolio to one that holds a mix of International stocks and US stocks has benefits. Despite a minimal change in the compounded annual returns of these portfolios since 1972, because of the added diversification, the withdrawal rate increases from 4.4% to 4.8%—A nearly 10% increase in retirement spending simply by diversifying internationally.  

Do Households Have A Good Sense Of Their RetirementPreparedness?  Munnell, Boston College.  The calculations show that even if households work to age 65 and annuitize all their financial assets, including the receipts from reverse mortgages on their homes, 52 percent will be at risk of being unable to maintain their standard of living in retirement… Do people at risk know they are at risk? [emphasis added]

The Consequences of Overestimating Retirement Expenses, Ken Steiner at Advisor Perspectives. Abraham Okunsanya, in his February 1, 2017, UK Finalytiq blog post, Busting the Myth of ‘U-Shaped’ Retirement Spending, cited research by the International Longevity Center-UK to support his statement, “An ideal sustainable withdrawal strategy should follow the typical spending pattern in retirement. This allows higher withdrawal at the early part of retirement and should progressively fall (at least in real terms) over their retirement period”… Despite research showing we spend less in real dollars as we age in retirement, many financial advisors continue to target constant real-dollar spending for their clients. In many cases, this is a result of inertia or software limitations.   [comment: many years ago, before I had read a single blog or research paper on retirement I had instantiated an age banding approach to retirement planning.  Seems like common sense.]


Selected titles…
- Management of Post-Retirement Finances for the Age 85 and Over Population
- Risk Strategies Pertaining to the Many and Diverse Risks Found in Retirement
- News Flash: Retirement Takes Over Long-Term Care
- How the American Retirement Savings System Magnifies Wealth Inequality
- Diverse Risks and Considerations in Retirement
- Women and Retirement Risk…
- Enhanced Risk Sharing Savings Accounts
- Dealing with Multiple Post-Retirement Risks in the Middle Market
- Understanding Reverse Mortgages:
- Bringing Economics and Actuarial Science Together: An Interview


Planning for a More Expensive Retirement, Blanchett, Finke, Pfau.  An important finding from this study is that a low-return environment would have a negative impact on client spending throughout their life cycle. 


Retirement’s Routes To Failure, Swedroe.  For example, Estrada shows that over the 86 30-year retirement periods he considered, a 4% withdrawal strategy from a global 60/40 portfolio would have failed 20 times, or in 23% of the periods. However, those 20 failures looked very different. In some cases, the plan failed with only two years remaining; in others, it failed with 14 years remaining. Those are two very different outcomes, with very different consequences. Yet they both count the same way in informing the failure rate. 


MARKETS AND INVESTING 

Contradicting Warren Buffett: When Volatility is Risk, Isaac Presley Cordant.  .  [ he is correct.  This is a common mistake made when one is over focused on single-period finance as in mean variance optimization.  In multi-period lifecycle finance, like retirement, where there are consumption constraints (leading to sequence risk and fail rates) and chaos processes from positive feedback loops (think bankruptcy when you weren't planning for it) vol can suck the wind out of your sails.  This is why some academics, economists among them, sometimes consider personal finance among the very hardest of economic problems.  Warren for all his genius is a single period guy not a lifecycle guy.]


Who are you competing with? Josh Brown Individual investors are lucky. They don’t need to engage in the type of short-termist behavior that monthly and quarterly performance measurement engenders. There’s no institutional imperative to be be seen as having been in the winning group for any particular period. There’s nothing wrong with average, if average is good enough to grow a portfolio toward the goals the investors have set for themselves. 

The Biggest Myths in Investing, Part 7 – Fees are a SmallPrice to Pay for Expert Advice, Cullen Roche.  I’m not gonna tip toe around this topic. My career in finance has convinced me that most financial firms charge way too much in exchange for the value they provide. The financial industry has gotten away with this for a long time because the average investor is woefully uninformed about financial matters, but as the Internet has democratized information and helped firms scale their businesses the high fee financial firms have come under fire. This is a fantastic development.  

A Study of Real Real Returns Now in its Third Decade, Thornburg.  Investors often focus only on nominal returns for portfolio construction, without considering the impact on inflation, taxes, and expenses… Instead of focusing on nominal returns, investors should consider the potential real real return of each asset class. The generation of real wealth, depends on it. 



 ALTERNATIVE RISK

The Golden Age of Hedge Funds, Ben Carlson.  “There are about 8,000 planes in the air and 100 really good pilots.” [quote from Ray Dalio] In 1998, there were around 3,200 hedge funds with roughly $210 billion in assets under management, according to estimates. Today, there are northwards of 11,000 hedge funds with assets totaling over $3 trillion. Size is the enemy of outperformance, and hedge funds are a perfect example of this… All of the new money that rushed into hedge funds created more competition for alpha. When hedge funds were smaller and nimbler, there was enough outperformance to go around. Now there are so many funds, algorithms, PhDs, mathematicians, computer scientists, and MBAs competing for pieces of a much smaller alpha pie. When you add in the exorbitant fees, what you get is worse performance. 

Firm-Specific Information And Momentum Investing, AlphaArchitect.  When it comes to momentum investing, everyone is always looking for a better way to implement a momentum-based stock selection strategy (the same goes for a value strategy). We highlight a few methods in our book, Quantitative Momentum, as well as on our blog. We recently came across a paper from 2006 that has an improvement on a baseline momentum investing strategy, titled “Firm-specific attributes and the cross-section of momentum.” 




Fake alpha, sr-sv.com  Statistical alpha can be divided into fake alpha, which is a premium for non-directional systematic risk, and true alpha, which reflects the quality of the investment process. Fake alpha arises from exposure to conventional factors that are not correlated with the market portfolio. Failing to distinguish fake and true alpha can be costly for investors and strategy developers. Fake alpha is easy and cheap to produce and after periods of high risk premia on conventional factors it can post impressive performance statistics (or backtests). Subsequently, investors overload on managers or strategies that use these factors and related performance inevitably deteriorates. This goes some way in explaining the negative historic alpha on actively managed funds. 

Moral Hazard In Hedge Fund Fees, Swedroe. The HWM feature is highly asymmetric and can be expressed as a long call-option position with a strike at the HWM. Therefore, hedge fund managers face a moral hazard issue because they have an incentive to increase risk when their previous performance has been disappointing. 

Investors Need to Get Comfortable with Being Uncomfortable, Adam Butler.   This new definition of risk profoundly shifts the conversation away from volatility and losses, and toward strategies that also achieve minimum required returns. From this new perspective, it is not sufficient to manage risk and provide downside protection; an investment strategy must also produce returns that fulfill long-term goals. Moreover, the strategy must account for the fact that investors are susceptible to shorter-term dynamics, such as tracking error relative to domestic benchmarks, which may run counter to the objective of long-term wealth maximization. In other words, advisors need to build portfolios that are financially optimal, but that investors can stick with over time. 


SOCIETY AND CAPITAL

International Corporate Tax Rates: Some Comparisons, Timothy Taylor.  It's common to think of the US as the rip-roaring home of market capitalism, at least as compared to most other high-income countries round the world. But this belief sits uncomfortably with the fact that US corporate tax rates are among the highest in the world. 

India’sDemonetization Experiment, AIER.  In this article, I will consider the potential rationale for banning most cash in India and some of the bad outcomes that can arise from such a decision. For such a policy to be defensible, it needed to do two things very effectively. First, it needed to have a well-functioning system in place to quickly replace the cash and reduce the burden on the millions of regular Indians who stood to be negatively affected. Second, it had to have major success in cracking down on the corruption it was meant to rein in. Only if both aims could be met would such a policy potentially be justified. Unfortunately, the early returns are not good on either score.

Disturbing New Facts About American Capitalism, Jason Zweig, WSJ.  Modern capitalism is built on the idea that as companies get big, they become fat and happy, opening themselves up to lean and hungry competitors who can underprice and overtake them. That cycle of creative destruction may be changing in ways that help explain the seemingly unstoppable rise of the stock market. 

Sources of Income Inequality among Households 65 and Older:Can Individual Choice, Markets and Public Policy Increase Equality? This paper explores the sources of income inequality among households aged 65 and older and the extent to which individual actions, competitive markets, and public policy can improve the financial well-being of those with low income. Three different types of retirement wealth are identified on the basis that they 1) are acquired in very different ways; 2) vary in their contribution to income inequality among older households; and 3) require unique individual behaviors and public policies to increase the income that they generate.  

Using Panel Tax Data to Examine the Transition to Retirement. Investment Company Institute and IRS.  Using panel data from the Internal Revenue Service’s Statistics of Income (SOI) Division, we find that most individuals do not experience a reduction in inflation-adjusted spendable income after claiming Social Security. We also examine the composition of income after claiming and find that both Social Security benefits and non-Social Security retirement distributions typically represent substantial shares of income. 

Extreme Poverty and Child Mortality
(embedded and animated. Hit the play button and watch China for example) 

Californiaexports its poor to Texas, otherstates, while wealthier people move in, Scramento Bee.  California exports more than commodities such as movies, new technologies and produce. It also exports truck drivers, cooks and cashiers. Every year from 2000 through 2015, more people left California than moved in from other states. This migration was not spread evenly across all income groups, a Sacramento Bee review of U.S. Census Bureau data found. The people leaving tend to be relatively poor, and many lack college degrees. Move higher up the income spectrum, and slightly more people are coming than going. 

No comments:

Post a Comment